Why So Much U.S.Support For WikiLinks Leaker PFC. Bradley Manning?

Posted: Sunday, August 8, 2010 | Posted by Chico Brisbane | Labels: ,

There is a growing support mechanism on the internet for U.S. Army intelligence analyst, PFC Bradley Manning. He was arrested in May 2010 and detained without charge for over a month in a military jail at Camp Arifjan in Kuwait.


In early July, two misconduct charges were brought against him for "transferring classified data onto his personal computer and adding unauthorized software to a classified computer system" and "communicating, transmitting and delivering national defense information to an unauthorized source".The maximum jail sentence is 52 years.


Manning allegedly told journalist and former hacker Adrian Lamo via instant messaging that he had leaked the "Collateral Murder" video (of the July 12, 2007 Baghdad airstrike), in addition to a video, approximately 260,000 diplomatic cables, where aledegly leaked to the whistleblower website Wikileaks. Lamo then turned Manning in by handing over the instant messenger chat logs to U.S. investigators, who began searching for evidence to determine whether Manning's apparent statements to Lamo were true. Hat's off to Lamo. Just because you're a hacker, doesn't mean your not patriotic.

The "Collateral Murder" video showed an attack by a U.S. helicopter crew on a group of men presumed to be insurgents. Two children were wounded, and thirty nine men were killed, including the father of the children and two men who were later identified as Reuters employees. Manning reportedly said that the diplomatic documents expose "almost criminal political back dealings" and that they explain "how the first world exploits the third, in detail."


Manning said that he hoped the release of the videos and documents would lead to "worldwide discussion, debates, and reforms." Well...he was almost right. There does seem to be worldwide discussion and debate. Except it's not so much over what is on the video, but rather if Mannings actions make him some sort of humanitarian hero, or a complete and utter discrase to the United States Military and a traitor to his country.
.
Of course Fox News is letting the chyron on the lower third of the screen do their reporting for them by ascerting, or asking the question really, should American Troops be killed as a result of what is on the video that Manning supposedly leaked, shouldn't murder charges apply to PFC. Manning? - A rediculous supposition in my opinion. To do so would make Manning responsible for the loss of every American Soldier between now and the last one standing at the fall of our republic. Hopfully that supposition is a thousand years away, but I doubt it.
As for what PFC Bradley Manning is charged with doing with the video, that is certainly open to debate. So, which is it? -

Is PFC Manning A Hero for pointing out the teh ugliness of war?

-Or-

Is PCF Manning a turn-coat that should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of military law should he be found guilty?

10 COMMENTS:

  1. Anonymous said...
  2. this guy is a traitor and should do the entire 50 years in prison.

  3. Anonymous said...
  4. I wouldn't exactly call him a traitor. But I think this is why the military has it's own judicial branch outside of the civilian judicial brnach, So secrets can remain secret.

  5. Anonymous said...
  6. FUCK THAT! Get a rope! Absolutely a traitor. He put his fellow soldiers lives in even greater risk than they already are. How does the saying go? He made his bed, now he's gotta lay in it.

  7. Anonymous said...
  8. so what? little kids can just be slaughtered in the street and that just fine and fucking dandy. you mother fuckers are sick! SICK SICK SICK

  9. Anonymous said...
  10. How does anyone know that these websites taking donations are legit?

  11. Joel Krause said...
  12. what was the harm in leaking the video? - everyone has a wild hair up their ass and they can't say what the damage was over leaking the video. I don't think any of you know what your talking about

  13. Chico Brisbane said...
  14. Here was my main point with all of this. The idea that friends and family would want Manning freed is understandable. But it's simply not an option. If anything, Manning is going to serve as a poster child for future militrary personnel, particularly those with an MOS in military intellegence that the leaking of information is serious business that carries serious consequences. Will Manning get locked up for 50 years? - I doubt it. But he should at least be a middle aged man before he's released from prison and allowed to continue on with what will be left of his misrable life.

  15. Anonymous said...
  16. ARE YOU PEOPLE FUCKING STUPID OR WHAT! WHY SHOULD HE GO TO JAIL, HE'S NOT THE BABY KILLER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!YOU THIN HE'S HE THE BAD GUY? WHAT ABOUT THE FUCKING PUSSY BABY KILLERS THAT HIDE IN THERE HILICOPTER TO KILL BABYS! THOSE FUCKING FAGGOTS ARE THE ONES THAT NEED TO GO TO FUCKING PRISON. FUCK ALL OF YOU MOTHER FUCKERS!!!!! FREE MANNING NOW

  17. Anonymous said...
  18. WHY TO FUCK YOU ALL MOTHERFUCKERS DONT GO TO
    MR MANNING CELL TO SUCK HIS COCK?YOU CAN ALSO
    TAKE YOUR MOTHERS AND SISTERS WITH YOU

  19. Anonymous said...
  20. Yes I think they are all stupid.

Post a Comment